CADC Statement on the Certification of the Petition to Recall Supervisor Joel Engardio

On May 29, 2025, the San Francisco Department of Elections officially certified that the petition to recall District 4 Supervisor Joel Engardio has met the necessary threshold of valid signatures. A total of 10,523 valid signers—exceeding the required 9,911—have made it clear: District 4 residents are ready for change.

As a result, a special municipal recall election will be held on Tuesday, September 16, 2025.

The Chinese American Democratic Club stands with the grassroots community members, families, and neighbors who worked tirelessly to make this possible. This movement was not led by paid operatives or outside interests, but by longtime residents who felt unheard, dismissed, and excluded by Supervisor Engardio’s actions and policies.

District 4 deserves leadership that listens, builds bridges, and serves all of its constituents—including immigrant families, Chinese American seniors, and working-class communities. The recall is a critical step toward restoring accountable, community-centered governance.

We encourage all District 4 voters to mark their calendars for September 16 and to make their voices heard in this pivotal election.

The future of our district is in our hands.

1 reaction Share

CADC Press Release: Overwhelming Validity Confirms Sunset District’s Recall of Joel Engardio Is a Movement

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE May 23, 2025 

Contact: 

Selena Chu: 1st Vice President
Julia Quon: Communication Chair
[email protected]

Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC)

BREAKING: Overwhelming Validity Confirms Sunset District’s Recall of Joel Engardio Is a Movement
San Francisco — The Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC) proudly congratulates the grassroots movement that has successfully pushed forward the recall of District 4 Supervisor Joel Engardio. This is a victory for Sunset District residents—a majority of whom are Asian Americans, and nearly half of whom are immigrants—who have been ignored, dismissed, and strategically silenced by the very official who was elected to represent them. <Read More Below>


華裔民主黨協進會(Chinese American Democratic Club - CADC)
突發消息:壓倒性的驗證結果證實:日落區罷免殷嘉立 (Recall Engardio) 已成為一場熱潮
舊金山 — 華裔民主黨協進會(CADC)熱烈祝賀日落區居民自發組織的草根行動,成功推動罷免第四區市参事殷嘉立 (Joel Engardio)。這是一場屬於社區、屬於民眾的重大勝利。日落區居民多為亞裔,其中近一半為移民,他們長期以來的聲音被忽視、被邊緣化,如今終於展現了集體的力量。<展開讀更多>
Read more
1 reaction Share

CADC Statement Regarding the Petition to Recall Supervisor Joel Engardio

The Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC) applauds the San Francisco Department of Elections' confirmation that the petition to recall Supervisor Joel Engardio has achieved a 99.3% validity rate in its 5% sample. This exceptionally high rate of accuracy reflects the diligence and grassroots strength of the campaign. Based on the sample, the Department estimates the campaign has reached approximately 106% of the required threshold for qualification.

While the automatic qualification threshold of 110% was narrowly missed due to a single duplicate signature in the sample, we are confident that the final manual count will confirm what we already know: the people of District 4 want their voices heard.

This recall effort is the result of thousands of conversations, community meetings, and neighbor-to-neighbor outreach. It is powered not by political consultants or corporate backers, but by working families, elders, and residents who feel unheard by their current representation.

Supervisor Engardio has consistently dismissed public input, made critical decisions behind closed doors, and accepted massive contributions from tech billionaires — all while ignoring the everyday needs of Sunset residents. We believe accountability matters. This validation result only strengthens our resolve.

We look forward to the Department’s final certification. In the meantime, we thank every volunteer and resident who made this moment possible.

Our voices matter. Our district matters. And we will continue to fight for leadership that respects and reflects our community.

 Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC)

1 reaction Share

Why do CADC and I support the Recall of Engardio?

This statement reflects CADC's position on the matter and outlines our commitment to transparency, accountability, and the values that have guided our club for decades.

As a third generation activist in this historic club, I deeply respect the commitment of our elders, who built the first and oldest Democratic club advocating for Chinese Americans and Chinese immigrants in this country. I’m proud of CADC’s legacy—not just in its history, but in how it’s stayed true to its values.

CADC has always stood for independence and accountability. We were the first Democratic club to support the school board recall, to oppose Prop K, and to hold elected officials accountable when they betray public trust. Our decision to join the recall of Supervisor Joel Engardio isn’t just about Prop K itself. It’s about something more serious: honesty and integrity.

Read more
1 reaction Share

CADC Congratulates Mayor-Elect Daniel Lurie

Dear Mayor-Elect Daniel Lurie,

On behalf of the Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC), I would like to extend our heartfelt congratulations on your election as the mayor of San Francisco. Your commitment to making our city safer, cleaner, and more inclusive has inspired countless residents across our diverse communities. We are eager to partner with you in bringing about the positive change that is so urgently needed. 

Read more
1 reaction Share

Yes on K Won. Is it worth it for the Moderates?

Proposition K (Prop K) for the November 2024 election cycle has been and will continue to be CADC's defining issue. As the election results have shown, CADC has reflected the Chinese and West Side voter sentiments. CADC also witnessed firsthand how Prop K has caused a cultural war and become a major distraction ruining the chances of many moderate candidates. Prop K also threatens to break apart the coalition that has been coalesced together gingerly in the past decade.

Read more
1 reaction Share

Letter to the Editor for Mission Local

Dear Mission Local Editors,

We are writing in response to your recent piece covering the annual dinner of our club, The Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC), that took place on June 1st.  As one of the oldest political clubs in the United States to fight for civil rights and anti-discrimination for Chinese Americans, we condemn the tone of the Mission Local piece that negatively portrays CADC and its contribution to empower and uplift the Chinese American and immigrant communities in San Francisco.

Read more
1 reaction Share

CADC 2024 President's Message

Serving as the first female president of the Chinese American Democratic Club in the 21st century, it’s my honor to speak to you today.

This is a pivotal year. We have the power to shape the future of our nation and our city. We have the power to uplift families, immigrants and young people in San Francisco for greater success.

Read more
1 reaction Share

Club Supports Call for Resignation of SF BoE Commissioner Boggess

At our June membership meeting, the Chinese American Democratic Club (CADC) voted on a motion from the Education Committee to ask San Francisco Board of Education Commissioner Kevine Boggess to step down from the Board President position. This motion was based on President Boggess's decision to back a Parent Advisory Council parent slate that was racially discriminatory and likely against state law. We provided ample time for President Boggess to present his side and answer questions. After the discussion, CADC membership voted to back the demand.
Read more
Add your reaction Share

Board Elections for 2023

At the December 8th Membership meeting, the attending members voted to renew expiring Board members (Michael Chan, Eddie Chin, Ron Lee, Jonathan Louie, Linda Quan, Victor Seeto, Sandy Su, Adlai Jew) to new three year terms as well as adding on two new Board members.

Read more
1 reaction Share